What Bollywood can teach you about India: Calendar Girls Edition

Here we are again, with another highly anticipated (I assume) post in my “What Bollywood can teach you about India” series. I know, you’ve been awaiting this eagerly, checking back here daily, just looking for another film recap/life lesson treasure trove. Well, look no further! Here we are.

Mr. India recently politely pleaded with me to stop making fun of movies he likes, because apparently my snarky comments are not as universally appreciated as they clearly should be. I can’t make any permanent promises, i.e., 90’s Bollywood Cinema, I’m coming for you! but in the spirit of marital happiness and nonsense things like that, this entry’s subject matter is sure to delight him, and hopefully you as well.

Ah, gentle reader, it is this moment when I must bring up a hotly debated subject, and that is, women in India. What are they good for? Having tons of children, obviously, overpopulation says what? but what ELSE? Lots of stuff! Like, looking good in clothing (that’s called modeling), or looking good in movies, (that’s called acting). And probably other things too, as we learned in Udta Punjab, women can also be doctors, if they are cool with getting stabbed, and migrant workers, if they are cool becoming sex slaves and heroin addicts. So you’ve got options, is the point.

In all seriousness, India has changed in its landscape of women and their role in the public sphere, from the northern adopting of the Mughal veiling and zenena or harem practices in the 1600s, to the kingdom of Kerala which was traditionally ruled by women, to the re-introduction of women in the public space as part of the Bengali Renaissance and the last queen of Kerala giving up her throne to a man (you can read about that here, I’ve heard the book is excellent), to Indira Gandhi, to the rise of women in the workplace, to the decline of women in the workplace (read this article if you want to be really sad). But India is still a place where child marriage runs rampant, dowry deaths happen every day, girls are treated as second class citizens, traded and commodified, forbidden to work, and made the policemen of their own virtue, blamed for sexual assault, judged for bare skin, viewed as property. Then, of course, there is the more insidious and subtle repression of the upper classes, the well-educated, which has its own pathways and projections, varying family to family and person to person (and marriage to marriage). Here, the concept of Western feminism is familiar, even longed for, but it’s hard to skip steps in terms of cultural paradigms and learned values, so you end up with women who like an idea of feminism that frees them, but find it at odds with the expectations of their families and even their own feelings about relationships and men.

And obviously, we will find that reflected in our Bollywood observations, will we not? So let’s tally up our Bollywood job count, so far we know of four jobs a woman can do in India, doctor, migrant worker turned sex-slave, model, or actress. COOL. Now, here is a fifth one! Calendar Girl! Which brings us to the title of our film, which is, in fact, Calendar Girls. What is a Calendar Girl? A Calendar girl is a girl who poses in a sexy way for a calendar, so like the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit edition but also telling you days and months and holidays and things like that. I have yet to see a sexy swimsuit calendar in India, but obviously I’m not looking hard enough, because the entire premise of this movie is that this is a real job that exists and is important. The director, Madhur Bhandarkar, has already made a movie about models, and one about acting, so the next obvious choice is this one, I guess.

Now, Bollywood Hungama says: “On the whole, Calendar Girls can be watched for its wholesome entertainment value, hard-hitting drama and engaging narrative.” As for me, on the other hand, I saw this movie over someone’s shoulder on a plane and I was intrigued and concerned, so when I got the chance to watch it on a digital platform I was like, yes, let me spend two hours of my life doing that. And boy am I glad I did, because the lessons, they were a coming! So, with no further ado, I present, Calendar Girls:

This is the calendar photographer, who talks about what a big deal this is. If it was REALLY a big deal, wouldn't it be HBO? Not Showtime? Heyo!

This is the calendar photographer, who talks about what a big deal this is. If it was REALLY a big deal, wouldn’t it be HBO? Not Showtime? Heyo!

This movie begins setting up the premise because again no one thinks this is a real thing or a real job, so the way they let the audience know how important it is to be a calendar girl is literally to say the title over and over and over again and talk about how BIG it is and how IMPORTANT it is and how the calendar is the OPPORTUNITY OF A LIFETIME like it’s an admission to college or a cruise or something instead of putting on a bikini and getting your photo taken.

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 10.45.55 PM

Lesson #1! Being a Calendar Girl might be the biggest thing you can do with your life in India. Men, sucks to be you!

So we get to meet all the Calendar girls and this is important because we are setting up CONTEXT and FAMILY STRUCTURE and DIVERSITY and all that matters a lot and then never matters again, for the most part.

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 8.08.20 PM

First, there is Mayuri, who is totally my favorite one. She is from this supportive selfie loving family in Rohtak, in Haryana. When you look up this town you get a bunch of news about rape cases so that’s…nice.

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 8.09.40 PM

Paroma, who wears the sad face of a family that doesn’t support her and an ugly scarf to go along with it, is from Kolkata.

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 8.11.07 PM

Nandita, from Hyderabad, is from a family of CEOs, because that’s a thing I guess, but she’s pretty excited to skate by on her looks. Also, how stiff is the competition for hottest Calendar in India? This is like winning “best Cambodian food in Oslo”.

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 8.13.48 PM

Nazneen, who is, gasp, Pakistani, leaves her boyfriend in London to do this calendar (what is the recruitment process for this like?) and his limited grasp of English shows in his choice of insult. It’s cheap HO, dude! The system fails so many…

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 8.14.32 PM

And finally, Sharon, from Goa, who is bright and ready for an adventure and has this terrible volume forward hair that is big here. You know what else is big? HER HORRIBLE SCRUNCHIE. YOU CAN DO BETTER, SHARON!

The guy who makes the Calendar looks like a woodland sprite but talks about why the Calendar is his favorite of his many businesses because in this digital age where porn is all over the internet I cannot image this paper calendar of scantily clad women doesn’t sell like gangbusters. Lesson #2! The best businesses are weird obsolete ones.

 

All the girls feel that the calendar will change their lives, but it’s very clear that it’s Sharon we should be plugging into because she’s doing it for all the right reasons, i.e. changing her life, not the wrong ones, i.e. having boys look at her body. Sharon just wants a bigger life! She symbolizes this by LITERALLY running away from her larger, tanner friend:

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 8.15.40 PM

Run, Sharon, before her small town mentality and less represented body contaminates you!

So anyway, these girls go to shoot this calendar, and the photographer, Timmy, gives them champagne and makes them talk about their sexual history because that’s a normal workplace conversation.

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 8.32.33 PM

Lesson #3! Before having your photo taken by a professional photographer in India, you need to tell them about losing your virginity. Sharon is candid, because that’s what Sharon IS, guys, god, Nandita spins a lesbian homework break fantasy, Paroma sets up a boyfriend who left her because of his ambitions, this will come back around again, Nazneen talks about her high sex drive, and Mayuri, my favorite, talks about making out with a boy in a barn because she’s still got her v-card firmly in hand. This never comes back again but I would totally watch a movie that is Mayuri going on a road trip to lose her virginity.

Then there is this photo shoot and you see the important and difficult work of being a calendar girl. I don’t know why there are five of them when there are 12 months, shouldn’t there be 12? Or at least 6 so everyone gets two months? Who decided this!?

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 10.45.31 PM

I love that they have this photo shoot with a lion. CALL PETA.

 

Right, so then the calendar comes out and instantly it changes lives! That’s what calendars do! Lesson #4, the calendar is not just a device of time-telling in India, it’s a portal to a new life!

 

Screen Shot 2016-07-10 at 11.28.05 PM

Paroma sees her ex at some Bengali function in Mumbai where she is the guest of honor (take that, parents!) and they are all flirty and whatever. They have all the chemistry of a physics class, so their whole thing is useless.

He looks like he would totally kill you and make a tent out of your skin.

He looks like he would totally kill you and make a tent out of your skin.

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.02.54 AM

Eventually they hook up, and you get to see right up her skirt, because this is how she dresses for events. Hey, if I had that body I probably would too.

Sharon meanwhile is working as a model until her agent spreads rumors that she is sleeping with him. I don’t really know why you would do this, as it sounds so terrible for business and also how does that get your client hired? But that’s Lesson #5 for you, most people in the entertainment industry are creepy leeches who care more about spreading a rumor that they’ve had sex with you than about getting you jobs which would pay them a commission.

Sharon is so mad she wasted this jumpsuit on this moment.

Sharon is so mad she wasted this jumpsuit on this moment.

Mayuri becomes an actress and she is amazing. I don’t know about her talent, but girlfriend PLAYS. THE. GAME. I feel like this is supposed to be negative for the audience, because she’s a little calculated and takes a job just for the money (which….IS WHAT A JOB IS), and I guess she’s supposed to be represented as dishonorable or whatever but I love her. She knows how important social media is so she cultivates her twitter following and leverages that into movie roles, she’s nice to everyone on set and posts selfies with everyone, director to camera crew, and she even teaches her manager a thing or two. I love her.

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 12.26.09 PM

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.15.00 AM

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.18.18 AM

She goes to a funeral and turns it into a PR opportunity. She could totally have a shot at winning the game of thrones.

I would watch a show that’s just her and her manager riding around in a car together, talking shop.

Nazneen, of course, because she is Pakistani, gets an acting job but then faces a weird specific protest against Pakistani actors, which I’m fairly certain isn’t a thing because this guy is Pakistani and he’s doing okay…

url

But anyway, Nazneen is literally protested like she goes to work and there is a protest just for her. Which, hey, that’s sort of thoughtful, right?

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 1.49.40 AM

So specific!

WRONG! It drives her directly into a life as a professional escort! Lesson #6, Pakistani immigrants in India are THIS CLOSE from becoming escorts. It’s a constant danger zone!

And Nandita! What’s up with her? So, she meets some guy at a party and he takes her to his stud farm (surprisingly not a euphemism) and he’s super rich and he’s like, marry me? And she’s like, I literally have no skills so why not!

 

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 12.31.47 PM

NO IT’S NOT. THIS IS EVERYTHING THAT IS WRONG WITH WOMEN BEING TOLD THAT MARRIAGE VALIDATES THEM AS HUMANS. ARRRRRRGH.

Sharon is blacklisted as an actress, but she then starts working in entertainment news and then becomes a hard news anchor in Delhi. That’s all fine I guess, whatever, it’s no Mayuri conniving her way onto a set and then WILLING the actress she plans to replace to get sick so she can take the role all while getting her ass a condo in Mumbai! Mayuri FTW!

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.32.32 AM

Nazneen, of course, is having a super horrible escort life and then when Nandita and Harsh, her playboy husband come to town, he hires her for the night.

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 1.34.05 PM

What could be sexier than telling a woman this?

Nazneen makes the sad faces of having sex with a friend’s husband against your will and it is the most acting this actress does all movie.

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 1.35.22 PM

Meanwhile, in what SHOULD be the most interesting plot line, Paroma gets involved with a cricket fixing scheme that is simultaneously very small but somehow also quite large? I don’t know, some cricket player wants to bang her, so her boyfriend is like, no, you shouldn’t, really, I don’t want you to, but…if you wouldn’t MIND, and she’s like, anything for you, Baby!

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 12.18.55 PM

She mostly just stands behind him in a bikini, but that seems to work for him, takes all types I guess, so he agrees to throw the game with some buddies. Man, cricket is really easy to fix!

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 12.24.20 PM

But unfortunately she’s too high off her victory to notice that cops are literally following her everywhere.

Also, this happens, and it’s amazing:

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 12.22.39 PMThey are literally throwing money around! Lesson #7, when you get a bunch of cash in India, you’re going to need to compile it and throw it around. That’s just the thing you need to do.

Oh, in case you were wondering, this is the face you make when your friend mentions her husband might be cheating on her and he was inside of you like, ten minutes ago:

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 1.44.18 PM

You can SEE this actress trying so hard. But her sad dead shark eyes eat emotion.

Nandita complains to her in-laws who are like, oh, honey bunny, it’s so weird that the guy you spent TWELVE HOURS WITH before agreeing to marry did this to you! But in our family, it’s just a form of stress relief. TRY YOGA, GUYS! Also, this family is rich, and you can tell because of their house:

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 1.58.01 PM

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.05.04 AM

Lesson #8! Being rich in India means you live in a weird Versailles knock-off surrounded by terrifying statues. I would not want to be rich here if this is the only way to do it…

Nandita cries sad tears, but what can she do, SHE HAS NO OTHER SKILLS. I guess now she can add “being cheated on” as a skill. Look at that, Nandita! Learning new things!

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.01.04 PM

 

Paroma gets caught by the police who are always following her and probably have become her next door neighbors and maybe also friends. They arrest her while she’s talking to school children which is a dick move. Lesson #9, the police in India have no tact.

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.10.12 PM

Her boyfriend has abandoned her, and her family bails her out but disown her a second time, because the first one didn’t stick I guess. Lesson #10, disowned comes with a do-over!

She then gets offered a reality tv show which she takes because much like Nandita she has no other skills. I mean, it’s no throwing money around, but what can you do?

Oh, and then Nazneen, who wants to quit the escort business, agrees to one last job, but then gets drunk and flees it and totally is hit by a truck and dies.

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.20.53 PM

But if that was too subtle an ending for you, don’t worry, Sharon, as always, has you covered:

Screen Shot 2016-07-11 at 2.22.11 PM

So in the end, Nandita is pregnant, Paroma is doing reality tv, Nazneen is 6 feet under, Mayuri continues to rule the world, and Sharon gets engaged to her boss? Which is random and makes no sense but HOW CAN YOU BE COMPLETE WITHOUT A MAN? HOW?

The worst part is? This movie, this insane totally out of control totally demeaning and strange and perverse movie, passes the Bechdel test. These women have relationships, they talk about stuff other than men, they have dreams and needs and goals and desires, but it’s all contextualized in this totally bizarre world in which being a Calendar girl is a real thing. Instead of owning their sexuality, they are all either trapped by it, or they escape it by being above such things. The characters who have sex, Paroma and Nazneen, are used, diminished, and left empty and with nothing. The characters who don’t, i.e. Sharon and Mayuri, triumph. Nandita gets caught in a trap of convention, but in the end she stays in it, content with her baby if not her marriage. For a movie about modern women, this film feels beyond dated.

But, at ten lessons, it’s not a bad bargain!

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “What Bollywood can teach you about India: Calendar Girls Edition

  1. Chris

    Really enjoyed this review, laughed and signed up for updates to your blog. Love that you have a feminist view…
    I spent 3 weeks in India decades ago. Except for walking to the near small town and and countryside, I was mostly in an ashram in Ganeshpuri.
    I live in southern California now.
    🙂 Chris

    Like

    Reply
  2. Pingback: What Bollywood Can Teach You About India: Dear Zindagi Edition | Sorry I'm Not Saree

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s